Morgan's interview with reality television star Snooki became a major topic of discussion on The Bobby Bones Show, starting with Snooki's claim that she was abducted by aliens when she was 13-years-old.
Morgan shared a clip from her podcast, Take This Personally, in which Snooki described seeing a UFO while swimming alone in her mother's pool. Snooki said the light appeared to communicate with her before disappearing. She later experienced what she believes was a real encounter involving three gray aliens, claiming they touched her neck and took her through a portal. Snooki said she still has a mark on the back of her neck that she believes was left behind during the experience. After hearing the clip, Bobby Bones asked the show members whether they believed Snooki had actually been abducted. Morgan said she believed Snooki because of how confident she was in telling the story and because the topic was not planned as part of the interview. Morgan added that Snooki did not appear to be seeking attention and seemed genuinely convinced of what happened. Amy did not think Snooki had been abducted, while Eddie and Lunchbox also not thinking it happened. Morgan noted that her interview revealed a side of Snooki that many people may not know, describing her as interested in paranormal topics and spirituality.
The conversation then shifted to how Morgan secured the interview, which led to frustration from Lunchbox. Lunchbox, who has long been vocal about being a fan of Snooki and other reality television personalities, said he felt "disrespected" that Morgan was given the opportunity to interview her. Bobby asked Lunchbox to explain his feelings, and Lunchbox said he believed he should have been considered for the interview. He suggested there should have been more discussion within the company before the opportunity was assigned. Lunchbox argued that people within the organization should have recognized his interest in Snooki and reality television personalities. Morgan reiterated that the interview opportunity did not originate from The Bobby Bones Show and came through other channels within the company. Amy agreed, saying the situation would have been different if someone directly on the show had chosen Morgan over Lunchbox. Since the opportunity came from outside the show's team, she did not believe anyone had intentionally overlooked him.
Lunchbox was also frustrated that Morgan's fiancé helped film content related to the interview. Morgan explained that her fiancé assisted by carrying equipment, setting up the interview, and capturing content while helping her complete the project. But Lunchbox doesn't think he should have been able to be there doing that and posting on his page. Beyond that, Lunchbox questioned the decision-making process that led to Morgan receiving the interview opportunity. He argued that larger platforms within the company should have been considered first like one of his.